Controversial subdivisons highlight lengthy planning and zoning meeting

By Darlene Denstorff The Ascension Citizen

The Parish Council isn't the only public body suffering lately from lengthy meeting featuring dozens of folks going to the microphone to express their concerns. Last Wednesday's Ascension Parish Planning and Zoning Commission meetings went on until 12:40 a.m. and saw the commission tackle several controversial subdivision and zoning issues.

After more than six hours of debate, the commission gave preliminary approval to Prairie Village Acres, weeks after construction permits were issued to the developer and delayed action on two others, Lake Martin Campsites North and Dutchtown Villas, after neighbors voiced complaints and concerns over development plans.

In addition, the zoning commission formed a task force to study the elimination of historical overlay zones regulating development within 1,000 feet of historical sites.

The Prairie Village issue was finally settled after months of wrangling. Parish President Harold Marchand recently issued a statement explaining his actions in issuing construction permits for the subdivision before preliminary approval was granted by the planning commission. Neighbors of the proposed subdivision, speaking at the Parish Council's Donaldsonville meeting earlier this month, questioned the construction of homes in what they said is an area suffering from congested traffic and poor drainage.

At the commission's Aug. 13 meeting, legal advisor Jessie LeBlanc tried to explain the complicated chain of events that led to the issuance of the permits prior to commission approval.

"Was it favoritism?" LeBlanc said in reference to the controversial permits. "No, that's not what happened."

She said a mistake was made by a parish employee when plans were approved before the commission gave its go ahead. She said the commission was made aware of the request or issuance of permits for lots 29-33 on at least three occasions.

She said the commission tacitly ratified the decision of the Parish President through its own actions.

Neighbors of the subdivision said they have attended public meetings to discuss the issue six times and continued their opposition by asking the commission to deny the subdivision.

"This is an election year and if you don't like what you see, vote," Cheryl Achee said.

Achee explained that the commission was voting on a preliminary plat approval for a subdivision that already has houses constructed.

"What's wrong with this picture?" Achee questioned.

Planning commission members, who are volunteers appointed by the Parish Council to the job and do not get paid, must first approve a preliminary plat before houses can be built.

"I want you to deny," Achee closed, banging her fist on the podium.

Neighbor Judith Bell said the commission originally denied plans to have the land now used for Prairie Village rezoned, but new zoning regulations by the council paved the way for the subdivision to develop without a zoning change.

"I'm going to wonder every time if a developer will go to DPW or the administration and disagree with the commission's actions," said commissioner Michael Marchand.

Commission chairperson Debbie LaCour said "nothing was hidden" during the process. Commissioner Kent Schexnaydre reminded the public that a flood overlay zone preventing development in the Prairie Village area was turned down by the council.

The commission approved preliminary approval with Marchand objecting.

The neighbors of a proposed Hwy. 74 subdivision delayed action after they questioned the planned destruction of a old live oak tree.

Shari Paxton, a 47-year-resident of the Dutchtown area living directly across the street from the proposed Dutchtown Villas development, said local historian Kermit Braud told her the live oak tree is at least 300 years old.

Braud explained Monday that the tree, planted by God generations ago, is a symbol "of what came before us and to even think about destroying it is unbelievable."

Braud is an avid supporter of a moratorium on residential development until traffic and drainage woes can be fixed. He said poor drainage and congested roadways plague current residents and parish representatives must work to protect the area's rural character and quality of life.

Braud said citizens have the right to express their views at public meetings concerning development. He said many fear retribution from developers if they publicly speak out against proposed subdivisions.

"We shouldn't have to go to meetings and beg. Our parish government should be representing the residents," Braud added.

Craig Corie, with Monroe and Corie, Inc., agreed to pull the request for Dutchtown Villas after the commissioners asked them to re-draw the lots to save the tree.

Corie said the tree takes up four or five front lots and presently is in the middle of the road of the 80-lot garden home subdivision. The developer said he would lose $125,000 if he had to save the tree.

However, he agreed to take another look at saving the tree after commissioners suggested that the area could be used for green space.

Developer and attorney Steve Joffrion agreed to pull his request for preliminary approval for Lake Martin Campsites North after residents complained about another subdivision he developed in the area.

Residents of a neighboring subdivision voiced strong opposition to Joffrion's campsite development, saying he did not follow parish rules at his Lake Martin Campsite East development and are "afraid he's going to do the same thing at" the new proposed development.

Neighbor Dee Dee Sanders presented the commission with a packet of information and complaints concerning Joffrion's last development. In addition, she and others presented a letter Joffrion sent to some of the neighbors.

Joffrion said the neighbors have been rude to him and he sent the letter to correct misinformation that was being spread.

Commissioner Brent Phillips encouraged Joffrion to meet with the neighboring homeowners before the next meeting to iron out any complaints. The commission agreed to let the residents express their concerns about the existing campsite subdivision at next month's meeting.

Sanders and others complained that Joffrion allowed a trailer, motor home and camp to be constructed without permits and wetlands regulations have not been followed.

The commission also granted preliminary approval for a mixed use residential development between Hwy. 74 and Hwy. 621 despite objections from residents complaining about the congested roads and poor drainage.

Residents said L. Landry Road, which will have an entrance to the subdivison, cannot handle the traffic volume from the proposed subdivision which will include garden and single family homes and apartments.