Flames of controversy die down between Hughes, fire boards

By DARLENE DENSTORFF The Ascension Citizen

The flames of controversy may have been extinguished last week when Parish President Ronnie Hughes sat down with volunteer firefighters from the parish's oldest fire board, but some are saying the "embers are still hot."

As Hughes spoke with members of Fire District 1 on June 22, across the parish at the Prairieville Fire Station, Chief Administrative Officer Jeff Smith met with Fire District 3.

Both boards said they wanted to speak with Hughes and members of his administration concerning statements the Parish President made at recent Parish Council meeting.

District 1 chairman Vic Palmer said he is taking a "wait and see approach" concerning healing between the fire board and the Parish President. Palmer and other fire board members "laid it out on the table" and discussed the fire protection contract with the City of Gonzales, the All-Star property issue, Hughes' idea to hire a paid fire administrator and comments Hughes has made in recent months concerning volunteer firefighters.

Fire District 3 went on record as opposing Hughes' proposal to hire a $45,000-a-year, full-time paid administrator.

At the District 1 meeting, Hughes apologized for recent statements, saying he did not intend to offend anyone and his statements may have been misunderstood.

After the meeting, Hughes called the session productive and "healthy" and asked members of the fire board to be "open-minded about change." In addition, Hughes said the meeting helped to create synergy between the fire board and his administration. Hughes said he hopes to end the "back and forth in the newspaper" concerning fire protection.

During the lengthy discussion, Hughes presented a letter from Mayor Johnny Berthelot concerning the intergovernmental agreement between the city and parish for fire protection outside the city limits. Since 2002, the parish has been paying $180,000 a year for Gonzales firefighters to respond to calls just outside the city limits to 4,385 residents, Palmer said.

In Berthelot's letter, the mayor said the $180,000 figure was arrived at because 30 percent of the department's emergency responses at that time were coming from outside the city limits. In 2001, $180,000 represented 30 percent of the fire department's $600,000 budget. Today, the parish is contributing 17 percent of the city's $1,025,000 budget.

"We are requesting an agreement that will last at least through your's and the council's elected term so we can develop a solid vision and service for the citizens we are protecting," Berthelot said in the letter to Hughes dated June 21.

Hughes said he met with the mayor just hours before meeting with the board.

"The mayor wants to know what you guys want," Hughes said. "I need to know tonight what you really want."

Palmer proposed the parish pay $19.25 per resident served. He said that figure is closer to what Fire District 3 is compensated by the parish's funding formula. Under the current contract with the city, he said, the parish is paying $41.85 per person for service in the designated area just outside the city limits.

"If this contract is abolished, both sides will take a hit," Palmer said.

After the planning committee meeting, the fire board met and formally made an offer to pay $19.25 per person served and requested that the city return all parish equipment.

Under the current contract, Palmer said, the city was to maintain equipment they received from the parish. However, Palmer said, one fire truck was in such bad shape volunteers couldn't start it for the 2003 Christmas Parade.

The proposal was to be discussed at Monday night's Parish Council Strategic Planning committee. The Parish Council and the Gonzales City Council have the final say-so on the contract. The contract is set to expire July 15.

During a discussion of when the board could move into the All-Star property, the history of why the parish did not contribute to the city's training center was outlined. Hughes has gone on record several times as being against the purchase of the All-Star property on Airline Highway. The fire board plans to use the site for office space, a fire training center and a substation. Hughes has repeatedly said a fire training center is not needed because they city already has one the parish could use.

Fire Board member Nat Stephens said the fire board was ready to pay the city $360,000 for use of its fire training center, but had to back out of the deal upon advice of the parish's legal counsel.

Fire Board Coordinator Gene Witek said the fire board was advised that it could not contribute money to the city for a training center if the city would not guarantee in writing how much time the parish would get to use the center. After the city's fire chief said he could not guarantee the parish any scheduled time, Witek said, the deal fell through.

Fire board members said "mistruths" concerning the funding of the city's training center have been made and they wanted to clear the air.

Hughes has also questioned the board's ability to use the All-Star property for live-burn training, and suggested that the board consider using the Sorrento Civic Center instead. Hughes asked the council back in March to give him permission to sell the All-Star site, but the council took no action.

The suggestion to sue the civic center met with opposition from at least one councilman in the audience. Councilman Jared "Burger" Beiriger questioned if the parish was going to "throw away" the money it had already spent on turning the Sorrento property into a golf course.

Jack Jones, a volunteer for the Sorrento Fire Department and a full-time firefighter in Baton Rouge, said plans for the fire training center call for "environmental friendly" live burns that will not have a negative impact on the area.

Palmer asked Hughes if he would assist the Fire Board in its attempt to occupy the All-Star property by "walking a permit through." However, Hughes said he didn't "walk through" any permits.

Palmer said folks with the local state sanitation office questioned why the Fire Board and not the parish was not applying for the permit.

Hughes said he had not placed roadblocks preventing the fire board from occupying the Airline Highway property. However, Palmer said Hughes' refusal to help out with the permit was a roadblock.

Hughes recommendation to hire a full-time chief or administrator also met with opposition from the District 1 board members and firefighters attending the meeting.

St. Amant Fire Chief James LeBlanc said a majority of parish fire chiefs discussed the idea of hiring an full-time fire chief during a conference in March in Gretna. While LeBlanc said the chiefs were in favor of "looking at the idea of hiring one chief...hear me good, we want to hire that guy."

"You get us the water and we'll hire the administrator," LeBlanc said.

While Hughes wants the proposed fire administrator to report to him, the fire chiefs want that person to report to the fire boards. LeBlanc said it is important that the fire chief understand fire service. He suggested that Hughes appoint someone in his administration to work with the fire boards "so we can handle our business into the meetings and not in the paper."

At the District 3 meeting, board members said the timing is not right for the new hire.

District 3 chairman Walter Leftwich said he is concerned the position could become political if appointed by the parish president.

"There has been a great deal of public discussion concerning difficulties between the administration and the fire service, and we are extremely concerned that this new person could be perceived as a way for the administration to wrest control of the fire service away from the Parish Council," said Warren L. Singer, District 3 secretary, in a letter dated June 23 to Hughes. "We think all these differences at large need to be assured that we have overcome our difficulties and are moving toward a better relationship."

Leftwich said the meeting did "help some," but said communications between the administration and fire boards must improve in order to allow the new district time to improve.