Lawsuit against sheriff, warden to continue

By Darlene Denstorff The Ascension Citizen

A federal judge has turned down a request by Sheriff Jeff Wiley and Warden Robert Webre to dismiss a lawsuit filed against them in connection with the alleged attack of an inmate in 2001.

U.S. District Judge James Brady refused the request for a summary judgment and instead said the suit, which alleges illegal practices at the Ascension Parish Prison, will proceed to trial.

The lawsuit, filed in U.S. district court in Baton Rouge, alleges that practices such as allowing inmates to choose their own cells led to a pretrial detainee being held hostage and raped for three days by maximum-security prisoners.

In a ruling made public last week, Brady decided not to dismiss claims that Paul Sanders of Gonzales was attacked because Wiley and Webre jailed the detainee with known violent inmates.

"This inmate had on five different occasion severy day the opportunity to let us know he was being harassed, abused. He never did. And one day he was out of jail on sick call and he didn't say a word," Wiley said.

"We run an accredited professional jail. But we admit we're not mind readers."

The judge also let stand for trial Sanders' contention that Ascension Parish Prison officials were responsible for the battering because they allowed prisoners to choose their own cells and failed to install a system for inmates to notify corrections officers of an emergency.

Sanders, who filed the lawsuit in 2002, was housed in the westbank jail after he was arrested in February 2001 after allegedly attacking his girlfriend. Sanders was unable to make the bond necessary for his release and remained in prison for about a month before the charges were eventually dropped.

In his lawsuit, Sanders claimed he was verbally threatened by other prisoners during the first two weeks of his detainment, but he did not inform guards of the threats.

The lawsuit contends other inmates later took Sanders hostage and repeatedly raped him for three days until a deputy broke up a fight. Sanders then reported the incident to guards, filed a formal complaint and was examined by prison medical personnel.

Several of those inmates were prosecuted and convicted in state court in connection with the assault, papers filed in the federal case show.

Brady wrote that Sanders must prove at trial that prison officials deliberately implemented a policy for classifying prisoners that resulted in violent inmates being housed with more vulnerable ones.

Also at issue, Brady wrote, is a long-standing practice in the prison allowing inmates to choose their own cells.

In his comments, Brady also raised concerns about whether the Ascension Parish Jail has a system through which prisoners can hail guards in an emergency, as required by Louisiana law.

Prison officials testified there are head counts five times a day and that inmates can initiate a distress call by waiving a white towel from a cell.

Wiley said Tuesday that jail personnel immediately investigated the attacks once Sanders let them know about them.