[agencyad:realmedia:by_state/la/gonz:news] The Ascension Citizen
Home

Local News

Sports

Classifieds

Obituaries

Guestbook

About Us

Archives

Health News

Entertainment

Town Hall

World News

Stocks

Road projects delayed again

By Darlene Denstorff The Ascension Citizen

The controversy over what firm should get engineering work for the Parish Council's 2003 road project continued at last week's council meeting without a solution.

The council did decide to send the whole issue to its infrastructure committee after attempts to give the engineering contract to a Baton Rouge firm failed. At least that's what Parish President Harold Marchand thinks took place at the council's April 3 meeting. Marchand and council secretary Suzanne Patterson were listening to the audio tape at presstime to decipher exactly what happened. Marchand said he may veto the resolution.

The council also agreed to have its infrastructure committee come up with a procedure for seeking proposals, or so-called RFQs, from consultants wanting to do business with the parish.

The entire mess started last month when the council voted to hire Glenn Shaheen and Associates to handle the $1.5 million road project. The council turned down a proposal from Pyburn and Odom MCA, Inc., a consulting engineering firm from Baton Rouge, to do the work for $108,000, some $60,000 less than the GSA proposal. Marchand vetoed the decision saying it would be fiscally irresponsible not to go with the firm that submitted the lower proposal.

However, questions about the Pyburn and Odom proposal and the process used to seek the two proposals caused Infrastructure Committee Chairman Shafter Kling to call the vote hasty and ask the council to reconsider the Pyburn and Odom proposal.

After a lengthy debate, a motion, substitute motion and amended resolution, the council voted, 5-4, to send the issue to the infrastructure committee. Patterson said according to her notes, the original motion, made by Councilman Adrian Thompson, called for the administration and Department of Public works to get with GSA to work out an agreement. Councilman Shafter Kling amended he motion to redirect the matter to the infrastructure committee.

The debate began last week with Council Alvin Thomas expressing his disgust over comments made by other councilmen about GSA. He said that while councilmen brought up four issues with GSA, "What about the 100 other things that firm had done? Why wasn't that talked about?"

He said he was embarrassed at the way the matter was handled and called GSA "a friend of the parish." Thomas asked the parish's legal advisor to look into the legality of the process.

"I do smell something fishy," Thomas said. "We need to spend more time getting projects completed and less time arguing over what consultants get the work."

Councilman Donnell "Nick" Nickens then asked the council to hire Pyburn and Odom.

Councilman Adrian Thompson said the personal attacks against GSA were "not right" and presented a substitute motion to direct Public Works director Bill Roux to meet with GSA and bring a new agreement to the council for consideration.

Roux reiterated his concerns over the GSA proposal which called for engineering fees of 11 percent of the project estimate compared to 7 percent for the Pyburn and Odom proposal.

"I have not said that GSA was a bad company." Roux said. "I only presented the facts."

Kling presented an "amended motion" to send the whole issue to the infrastructure committee and finalize a request for qualification process.

Kling said Monday morning that he did not favor renegotiating with GSA and instead wanted to start the entire process over after RFQ guidelines are finalized. He said the road project could be delayed by about six weeks.

Kling said he envisions four or five companies submitting proposals when the dust settles.

Mark DeBosier with GSA disputed comments made that the two proposals were similar. However, Pyburn and Odom president Rudi Aguilar, an LSU professor, said the matter was so simple that he would give a student an "F" if he chose the GSA proposal in an assignment based on the issue before the council.

"It's not that simple," DeBosier countered, adding that his company presented a detailed proposal based on their experience in the parish.

"Maybe they (Pyburn and Odom) don't understand the scope of the project and maybe DPW doesn't understand the scope of the project," DeBosier said.

Councilman Dudley Brown said the entire confusion is the very reason the council needs to accept a RFQ process.

"What I'm seeing here is politics at its best," said Thomas. "If GSA needs to be run off then lots of others need to be run off."

Council Chairman Thomas "Moose" Pearce said the administration was "politically motivated" in its decision to seek just one other proposal for the engineering work. He said the administration should focus its efforts on saving money by looking at the "close to $5 million" in added salaries and benefits since taking office.


[agencyad:realmedia:by_state/la/gonz:bottom]
[agencyad:realmedia:by_state/la/gonz:emporium]
s

[ Home Page ][ Local News ][ Sports ][ Classifieds ][ Obituaries ]
[ About Us ][ Guestbook ][ Archives ][ Health ][ Entertainment ][ Town Hall ][ World News ][ Stocks/Market ]